Three years ago I taught a Wednesday night class on the Psalms and built the whole quarter around the good ones, the ones that end with a lifted chin. I got to Psalm 88 in week nine, read the first four verses, and heard myself say, “We’ll skip this one. It’s a downer, and there isn’t much in it for us.”
A woman in the back row had buried her husband in April. She waited until the room cleared, then said, “That’s the only one I read anymore.”
I went home and read the whole thing at my kitchen table, twice. It does not lift its chin. It ends with the writer’s friends gone and the darkness standing where they used to be. No turn, no resolution, no tidy last line I could underline and put on a coffee mug. I had been in ministry for eleven years and had never once preached it.
The Psalms I Had Quietly Filed Away
Here is what I had absorbed without anyone ever teaching it to me: the psalms were for morning devotions and hard seasons that resolve by verse 6. The sad ones were background music. I treated them the way I treat the fine print on an insurance form, technically present, not meant to be read closely.
That was not honest to the book. Scholars who sort the psalms by type keep arriving at the same uncomfortable count: lament outnumbers praise. I had been preaching a canon I had edited down to the parts that made me look like a competent spiritual leader, which is a polite way of saying I had been trimming the Bible to fit my own comfort.
What Psalm 88 Actually Does
Look at how it opens. “O LORD, God of my salvation; I cry out day and night before you. Let my prayer come before you; incline your ear to my cry!” (Psalm 88:1-2, ESV). He calls God his salvation in the same breath he calls himself a man in the dark. That pairing undid something in me. I had been taught that confident faith sounds confident. This man’s faith sounds like an argument at 3 a.m.
The psalm gets worse before it stops. The writer blames God for the isolation, not his circumstances. “You have caused my beloved and my friend to shun me; my companions have become darkness” (Psalm 88:18, ESV). Then the poem simply ends. Hebrew poetry usually circles back; this one walks out of the room.
For a long time that felt like a mistake in the editing. Now it reads like a door left open on purpose. If the Bible can carry a prayer that ends in darkness, then a prayer that ends in darkness is still a prayer. The person who cannot find the closing line is not outside the book. They are in it, quoted.
The Psalm I Had Been Misusing
Psalm 13 was my favorite for years, and I loved it for the wrong reason. I loved the ending and skipped everything before it. What I skipped is four questions in a row: “How long, O LORD? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me? How long must I take counsel in my soul and have sorrow in my heart all the day? How long shall my enemy be exalted over me?” (Psalm 13:1-2, ESV).
Four how longs. Not one, which could be passed off as rhetoric. Four, which is what a person sounds like on the fourth month.
What I had been doing was quoting verses 5 and 6 at people in the hospital, the part about trusting in steadfast love and singing to the Lord, as if the psalm were a vending machine: insert complaint, receive chorus. But the turn in verse 5 does not erase verses 1 through 4. It arrives after them, from inside them. David argues with God for four verses before he trusts him, and the arguing is not the failure. The arguing is the relationship.
I learned that the hard way in the year my father’s memory started going. I would sit in my car in the parking lot of his care home and read Psalm 13 out loud with the windows up, and I did not feel better. I felt less alone, which turned out to be the thing I actually needed. There is a difference between a God who fixes the parking lot and a God who meets you in it.
How I Read a Hard Psalm Now
I don’t do anything clever with these texts. Four steps, about fifteen minutes.
Read it out loud, all the way through, without rescuing it. The temptation is to stop at verse 8 and start explaining. Don’t. Let the last verse land where the poet left it.
Write down the line that makes you flinch. For me it was “your wrath lies heavy upon me” (Psalm 88:7). I did not want a God with wrath in his vocabulary. Writing the line by hand forced me to admit I had been avoiding it, and then to ask why.
Do not add a “but” the text doesn’t have. This is the whole discipline. If the psalm ends in the dark, my prayer ends in the dark. God is not fragile. He can be addressed at the bottom of the well, and the psalms prove he expects to be.
Pray it back as written, in the first person. Not “the psalmist says” but “I cry out day and night before you.” It feels wrong the first ten times. It felt wrong to me for a month. Then one Tuesday it stopped feeling wrong, and I noticed I had been praying honestly for the first time in a while.
Paul says something about this that I had read past for years: “For whatever was written in former days was written for our instruction, that through endurance and through the encouragement of the Scriptures we might have hope” (Romans 15:4, ESV). The encouragement he has in mind comes through endurance, not around it. The sad psalms are how Scripture encourages a person who has not yet been rescued.
What It Did to Our Group
The following spring I taught the class again and started with Psalm 88 on purpose. I asked the woman who had spoken to me to read it. She read it slowly, all eighteen verses, and when she finished, two men who had said maybe forty words all year started talking about their own dark rooms. We spent the next four weeks in the laments. Nobody asked for the happy ones.
What changed was not the material. It was that I stopped editing the psalter for the room. The material matters less than permission. A group will stay on the surface for as long as the leader stays there, and the psalms give a leader somewhere honest to stand.
If you are the one holding the bag for a group and you do not have a spare month to build a study from scratch, we put together an eight-week kit called Peace for Anxious Hearts: Philippians and the Psalms, forty-five minutes a session, no prep required. Week 1 is free as a PDF, so you can read the actual format before you spend anything: see the 8-week small-group kit and download Week 1.
One Thing to Try This Week
Pick Psalm 88 or Psalm 13 and read it out loud alone, slowly, twice. Then write one sentence to God that you would not say in church. Keep it in your Bible where you will find it in six months. You do not have to feel anything while you do this, and you do not have to arrive at hope by the end of the page.
The psalms never require you to be alright before you open them. That is why the sad ones are still in the book, and why the woman in the back row knew where to go when the rest of us were still picking the happy ones.