I Kept a List of Unanswered Prayers for Two Years. Here’s What Changed When I Read It Again.

I started the list on a Tuesday in March. My husband had just lost his job, our daughter had strep throat for the third time that winter, and I was sitting in the school pickup line crying quietly so the kids wouldn’t see. I opened my phone’s notes app and typed one sentence: God, please help us. Then another. Then another. By bedtime I had seven prayers on the list, and I told myself I would check them off when God answered.

I remember the night he told me. We were at the kitchen table after the kids were asleep, and he didn’t look at me when he said it. I made tea that went cold. We didn’t pray that night. We just sat there, and I realized I had no idea how to ask God for help when I was the one who was supposed to have it together.

Two years later, I still had seven unchecked items.

The list became my whole prayer life

For months, every morning began with those same seven sentences. Please provide. Please heal. Please change his mind. Please make this easier. I said them like a mantra, checking the sky for a sign, checking the mailbox for an answer, checking my husband’s face for evidence that something had shifted. Nothing did.

The seven items were specific, because I was desperate enough to be specific. That the job loss wouldn’t mean losing our house. That our daughter’s strep would stop coming back. That a certain friendship I had damaged would be repaired. That my husband would find work quickly. That I would stop waking up at 3 a.m. with my heart pounding. That our marriage would survive the stress. That God would explain, eventually, why this was happening.

I began to dread my prayer time. Not because I stopped believing God could act, but because I felt like I was nagging him. Every unanswered item felt like a small proof that either I wasn’t praying hard enough, or God wasn’t listening, or I had misunderstood the whole thing. I kept the list anyway because I didn’t know what else to do.

There was one night our daughter woke up vomiting at 2 a.m., and I stood in the bathroom holding a cold washcloth to her forehead while I ran through the list in my head. Please let this be the last time. Please don’t let it be something worse. By 4 a.m. she was asleep again, and I was wide awake, angry at God and angry at myself for being angry. That was when I realized prayer had become a transaction to me: I put in the right words, and I expected a result. When the result didn’t come, I assumed the arrangement was broken.

What changed when I read it again

I found the list by accident. I was clearing out old notes to make space on my phone, and there it was, dated March 2024. I read each item slowly. Three of them had, in fact, been answered — just not in the timeframe or the form I had asked for. The job my husband got paid less than his old one, but it had better hours, which meant he was home for dinner most nights. Our daughter eventually outgrew the strep cycle. The friendship I had begged God to restore never did restore, but I stopped needing it to.

Four items remained unanswered. One still does today.

Reading the list changed something in me. I saw that I had been measuring answered prayer by my calendar and my preferences. God was operating on a timeline I couldn’t see, and he was not obligated to explain it to me. The Bible never promises that he will.

What Scripture says about waiting

David wrote, “How long, Lord? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me?” (Psalm 13:1–2). That psalm ends with praise, but it begins in the same place my list did — with waiting, and with the honest sense that God is silent.

God told Isaiah, “For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways” (Isaiah 55:8–9). I had been measuring answered prayer by my calendar and my preferences. God was operating on a timeline I couldn’t see.

Jesus told the parable of the persistent widow to show his disciples “that they should always pray and not give up” (Luke 18:1–8). Not because nagging wears God down, but because prayer shapes the one who prays.

And Lamentations reminds me that God’s mercies “are new every morning” (Lamentations 3:22–23). Not new every time I get it right, or every time my situation improves — every morning.

How I pray now

I don’t use the list anymore. I don’t check items off. I talk to God about the day as it happens — the bad traffic, the hard conversation, the small gratitude of clean sheets and hot coffee. When I don’t know what to say, I don’t say anything. I just stay.

Sometimes I pray while I fold laundry, or in the carline, or lying in bed in the dark. I don’t always finish my sentences. I’ve learned that an unfinished sentence is still a prayer.

My kids have started asking what I’m doing when I close my eyes in the middle of the day. I tell them I’m talking to God, the same way they talk to me when they’re scared. They don’t care about eloquence. They just want to know someone is listening.

Two years ago I thought faith meant believing God would answer my prayers the way I wanted. Now I think faith means keeping company with him whether he answers on my schedule or not. The list taught me that much.

If you’re in a season of unanswered prayer, you don’t have to figure it out alone. Our small-group kit walks through eight weeks of Scripture and discussion designed for exactly this kind of season. It’s $29 for an individual and $89 for a church license, and you can read Week 1 as a free sample before you decide. Download the sample here: small-group kit.

I still keep a notes app on my phone. These days, though, I use it to write down what God has already done, not only what I’m waiting for. I hope it gives you a place to bring your list, whatever’s on it.

Get Your FREE 30-Day Prayer Guide
Plus a short weekly devotional in your inbox. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime. Browse all free resources →  ·  Every study by topic →

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top
Share Christian Faith Web   ♥ Share on Facebook